In the diverse world of real estate investments, short-term rentals hold a unique position, especially when it comes to tax reporting and the nature of income they generate. The distinction between passive and ordinary income, as well as the services provided during the rental period, heavily influences how these earnings should be reported to the IRS. This article explores the differences between rentals of more than 7 days with minimal services versus rentals of less than 30 days with substantial services, outlining the tax implications for each scenario.
Rentals of More Than 7 Days with Minimal Services
Tax Classification and Reporting: When a rental period extends beyond a week but lacks substantial services, such as daily cleaning or meal services, the income generated is considered passive. Passive income is generated from enterprises in which an individual is not actively involved on a regular, continuous, or substantial basis. For landlords, this typically includes properties where the primary return on investment comes from the appreciation of the property and the income from rent, rather than from recurrent and direct management efforts.
Tax Reporting on Schedule E: Such income should be reported on Schedule E (Supplemental Income and Loss). This IRS form is used for reporting income and losses from rental properties and is indicative of a more hands-off investment strategy. Schedule E is particularly suited for situations that mirror traditional, long-term rental activities where the interaction between the landlord and the tenant is minimal and primarily revolves around the upkeep and maintenance of the property.
Tax Implications of Passive Income: Passive income is not subject to self-employment taxes, which covers Social Security and Medicare. However, one downside is the limitation on deducting losses. If your expenses exceed your rental income, you can only deduct these losses from other passive income sources. For taxpayers with modified adjusted gross incomes below a certain threshold, up to $25,000 of passive losses may be deductible against non-passive income.
Rentals of Less Than 30 Days with Substantial Services
Tax Classification and Reporting: Conversely, when a rental lasts less than 30 days and includes substantial services that enhance the guest’s stay, the income is classified as active. These services may include daily cleaning, providing meals, concierge services, and more, which necessitate ongoing, substantial involvement from the property owner or manager. This operational intensity shifts the nature of income to what is termed as “ordinary income.”
Tax Reporting on Schedule C: This type of income should be reported on Schedule C (Profit or Loss from Business), which is used for income earned from business activities. Reporting on Schedule C allows landlords to deduct a broader range of business expenses directly related to the active management of the property.
Tax Implications of Ordinary Income: Ordinary income generated from active rental management is subject to self-employment taxes. However, it also opens the possibility for more deductions, including business expenses that are ordinary and necessary, such as salaries for staff, marketing expenses, and supplies. Furthermore, income reported on Schedule C may qualify for the Qualified Business Income Deduction under the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, potentially reducing the tax burden by allowing a deduction of up to 20% of qualified business income.
Key Differences Between Passive and Ordinary Income
- Nature of Involvement: Passive income involves less direct, ongoing management, whereas ordinary income generally results from more direct, continuous business activities.
- Tax Treatment: Passive income avoids self-employment taxes but has restrictions on loss deductions, while ordinary income is subject to self-employment taxes but allows for broader expense deductions.
- Reporting Forms: Passive income is reported on Schedule E, and ordinary income is reported on Schedule C, reflecting the different levels of activity and involvement in the income-generating process.
Conclusion
The tax consequences of renting out property on a short-term basis can vary significantly based on the duration of the rental and the level of services provided. Property owners must carefully assess their level of involvement and the services they offer to determine the correct way to report their income. Consulting with a tax professional, particularly one familiar with real estate tax law, is recommended to navigate these complexities effectively and ensure compliance while optimizing tax liabilities.
Please feel free to contact us at 415-860-6288 or via email at info@flextcg.com or visit Book An Appointment – Flex Tax and Consulting Group (FTCG) (flextcg.com) to schedule a consultation.
Reference:
https://financialsolutionadvisors.com/blog/do-rental-property-owners-file-schedule-c-or-schedule-e/
